Friday, September 2nd: Course Introduction
Today we’ll have a chance to meet the faculty of the Classics department and to share some of our initial ideas for thesis projects. We’ll also have a visit from Margaret Schaus, Haverford’s research librarian for Classics. So that we can get underway quickly, there are a few things I’d like to ask you to do before our first meeting.
Required Post
Take a look at the instructions for posting to the course website. Set up your login, nickname, and avatar.
Before our first class meeting today, post your initial idea for your thesis to the course website: you’ll find instructions for this post here. This will be a reflection, in writing, that can include your questions, hesitations, thoughts, hopes, and dreams.
Required Assignment
Before class today, complete the start of term survey.
Readings
View and take careful notes on the following tutorials prepared by our research librarians. You can find the complete set of tutorials here if you’d like to revisit any of these or explore others.
- Required
Margaret Schaus, Haverford’s research librarian for Classics, will be visiting our class today. As you work through these tutorials, please note down at least one question or topic you’d like to discuss with Margaret during her visit.
Friday, September 9th: Antiracism and Classics
Sign Up
Before class today, click here to sign up for a date for your thesis workshop. You can read all about hosting a workshop here.
If you have already made some progress with your thesis (e.g. during a summer research program), I would encourage you to sign up for an earlier date, so that students who are just beginning their thesis work have more time to develop their ideas.
Readings
- Required
- Selections from Ibram X. Kendi, How to Be an Antiracist (Introduction, Definitions, Power, Culture)
- Note: My scanner for some reason cannot read the fancy drop cap initial letter of each chapter, so you’ll have to fill them in from context! You can also read the library’s copy online here, but only one person can access it at a time.
- Kwame Anthony Appiah, “There is No Such Thing as Western Civilization“
- Patrice Rankine, “The Classics, Race, and Community-Engaged or Public Scholarship“
- Selections from Ibram X. Kendi, How to Be an Antiracist (Introduction, Definitions, Power, Culture)
- Optional
- Further selections from Ibram X. Kendi, How to Be an Antiracist (Dueling Consciousness, Class, Gender, Sexuality)
- Nandini Pandey, “Out of Africa“
- Dan-El Padilla Peralta, “Barbarians Inside the Gate” (Part 1; Part 2)
- Pria Jackson, “Fight or Die“
- Rebecca Futo Kennedy, “We Condone It By Our Silence“
- Denise E. McCoskey, “What Would James Baldwin Do?“
Required Post
Before the start of class today, post at least two comments on Discussion: Community Standards. Before the end of the weekend (Sunday, 9/11, 5:00pm eastern) post a third comment.
Required Assignment
Before class today, email your “Lay of the (Research) Land” to Prof. Farmer.
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. No one needs to do all of these, but each has a specific deadline, and if you skip too many, you’ll miss your chance to earn the grade you want. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Antiracist Classicism 1.
Friday, September 16th: Black Feminist Classics
Readings
- Required
- Shelley P. Haley, “Be Not Afraid of the Dark: Critical Race Theory and Classical Studies“
- Shelley P. Haley, “Black Feminist Thought and Classics: Re-Membering, Re-Claiming, Re-Empowering“
- Tracey L. Walters, “Writing the Classics Black“
- Phillis Wheatley, “Niobe in Distress for her Children slain by Apollo, from Ovid’s Metamorphoses, Book VI. and from a view of the Painting of Mr. Richard Wilson”
- This poem will be the focus of much of our conversation in class today. You can see the instructions for the work we’ll be doing here.
- Optional
- Emily Greenwood, “The Politics of Classicism in the Poetry of Phillis Wheatley“
- Eric Ashley Hairston, “The Trojan Horse: Phillis Wheatley“
Community Standards
If you have time, I would encourage you to read back through the full Community Standards discussion forum before class today, to get a sense of the overall conversation.
Required Post
Before class today, post your “Questions Please” assignment to the course webpage (as an independent post, not in a comment in a discussion forum).
Mentorship
Before class today, meet with at least two faculty members (those suggested by Prof. Farmer, or others) to discuss your ideas for your thesis. Email Prof. Farmer a very brief (2-3 sentences) description of the conversations you had.
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. No one needs to do all of these, but each has a specific deadline, and if you skip too many, you’ll miss your chance to earn the grade you want. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Antiracist Classicism 2 [remember that if you did Antiracist Classicism 1, you must choose a different option for this assignment].
Friday, September 23rd: Re-Rooting the Tradition
Readings
- Required
- Emily Greenwood, “Re-Rooting the Classical Tradition“
- Robert G. O’Meally, “Romare Bearden’s Black Odyssey: A Search for Home“
- Spend some time exploring the art of Romare Bearden through some of the following sites:
- Optional
- Preview the slides we’ll be working with
- Patrice Rankine, “Classica Africana“
- Excerpts from “Bearden’s Odyssey: poets respond to the art of Romare Bearden“
Required Post
Before class today, read and comment on at least two other students’ “Questions Please” posts. Make sure to take a look at your own post before class to see what comments have been left for you; you’re welcome (but not required) to respond to them as well!
Required Assignment
Before class, email your “Preliminary Bibliography” to Prof. Farmer.
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Just Classics Manifesto OR a third option from “Anti-Racist Classicism“.
Friday, September 30th: Layla & Claire
Required Assignment
Send “Writing Into Your Thesis 1” to Prof. Farmer.
Layla’s Workshop
Partner: Laken
Primary Readings
DO NOT TRY ANY OF THE REMEDIES LISTED IN THESE TEXTS. Consult a licensed medical professional for treatment. CONTENT WARNINGS: These texts include bodily fluids, including those involved in infection. There is also vivid anatomical description involving sexual organs.You will be very confused and that is normal. These anatomical descriptions and remedies are very different from modern medicine. I will explain some of the jargon in class, but you are welcome to simply google it if you don’t want to wait.
- Galen On the Anatomy of the Uterus
- skim this if you don’t have time
- Hippocrates’ On Diseases of Women, Book 1, Chapters 7 and 11
- Kahun Gynecological Papyrus
- skim for parts specifically mentioning the uterus and possible agencies that it has such as movement, smell, consumption, etc.
Secondary Readings
- Faraone, Christopher A. “Magical and Medical Approaches to the Wandering Womb in the Ancient Greek World.” Classical Antiquity 30, no. 1 (2011): 1–32.
- Read the introduction and conclusion if you don’t have time for anything else.
- Optional: Freidin, Anna Bonnell. “Animal Wombs: The Octopus and the Uterus in Graeco-Roman Culture.” Classical Philology 116, no. 1 (January 2021): 76–101.
- If this link gives you trouble, navigate your way to the correct issue here.
Data Set
- Take a look at some of these womb amulets.
- What do you notice are trends? What can you imagine they could have been used for? What does the object ask you to do with it?
Claire’s Workshop
Partner: Rose
Secondary Readings
- Edmonds III, Radcliffe G. Redefining Ancient Orphism: A Study in Greek Religion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.
- Available on Tripod and through Cambridge University Press.
- Read Chapter Three: The problem of definition. If time is an issue, focus on reading at least pgs 71-82.
- This chapter gives a good introduction to thinking about what makes something “Orphic,” but also frames the idea of “polythetic categories,” the methodology that I will be working with. Here, Edmonds looks at Orphism itself as a polythetic category; I believe that this framework can be applied much more broadly, and things like “gender,” “the divine,” and “bodies” can all be looked at as polythetic categories.
- Read part of Chapter Six: Orphic Mythology: The content of Orphic poems. Specifically, it would be helpful to read the section on Orphic Cosmogony, pgs 162-172.
- Orphic cosmogony relies on familiar tropes, but inverts and subverts them in surprising ways. It might be helpful to take a look at this explanation of Orphic stories of creation.
Primary Readings
Read these texts with these questions in mind:
- How do these texts build the bodies of their divinities?
- How is the gendered body constructed, or more generally, how is the divine gendered?
- What is the role of the body/the gendered body in Orphic cosmogony? (Cosmogony = the creation of the cosmos/universe)
- Also a note: these texts are super weird and there are so many varied readings of both. So feel free to have your own take on them, and also don’t worry about not understanding what they’re about. Scholars have been debating that exact question for decades and still don’t have a satisfactory answer.
The Derveni Papyrus
- The best/only translation that doesn’t attempt to fill in the lacunae of the papyrus is the one on Loeb; if you access Loeb Classical Library through Tripod (BMC; HC) and search “Derveni Papyrus,” it will take you right to the translation.
- It would be great if you could skim the whole thing; realistically this might not be possible, so I would focus on Col. XII – XXIII.
- This section is super weird, but has some of the most interesting bodily descriptions.
The Orphic Hymns
- Download texts and transations
- Note to the English translation – there is currently no satisfactory English translation of the Orphic Hymns; I am using Athanassakis’ translation, but Ricciardelli’s Italian translation is currently considered the most accurate and is referred to by most scholarly work on the Hymns.
Friday, October 7th: Elise & Eden
Required Post
Before class today, post your “Thesis Portrait” assignment as a new post on the course webpage.
Mentorship
Before class today, reach out to your assigned thesis advisor to set up a meeting to discuss your plans and progress. Once you’e been able to meet with your advisor (not necessarily by this deadline), email Prof. Farmer a short (1-2 sentences) description of your conversation.
Elise’s Workshop
Partner: Hannah C.
Readings
- Sententiae Antiquae’s summary and translations of the Batrakhomuomakhia (Battle of Frogs and Mice)
- Optional: audiobook for people who prefer to listen to texts
- “Translation as a Battlefield: Dryden, Pope and the frogs and mice”
- The War of the Mice and the Crabs
- You only need to read the “Translator’s Introduction”, but I include links to the entire book in case curiosity strikes.
Eden’s Workshop
Partner: Alexander
Readings
- Homer’s Odyssey
- HOMER, Odyssey | Loeb Classical Library (loebclassics.com)
- AND/OR: Homer (c.750 BC) – The Odyssey: Book XII (poetryintranslation.com)
- Book XII, lines 36-110, 111-164, 201-259
- Article: Do I Have Something in My Teeth? Vagina Dentata and its Manifestations within Popular Culture
- Please read the abstract, and the introduction and section on Teeth that are available in the preview.
Fall Break
No classes Monday October 10th – Friday October 14th
Friday, October 21st: George & Celine
George’s Workshop
Partner: Liam
Readings
Content warning: within these poems and readings there is frequent mention of forced penetrative sex being used as a form of punishment. For the most part, the action is simply stated rather than described in detail, but there is still some rough content. Please feel free to only read what you want from the optional secondary readings, and to skim/pass over some of the poems if you are uncomfortable with them.
- Carmina Priapea (selections)
- Optional: Selections from Craig A. Williams, Roman Homosexuality
Celine’s Workshop
Partner: Marion
Readings
Content warnings: derogratory language, violence (against and by women; threats of), sexual violence, blood, slavery, incest, death (esp. murder).
- Adrienne Rich, “When We Dead Awaken: Writing as Re-Vision” (1971)
- Audre Lorde, selected poems: “Oya” (1974), “A Woman/Dirge for Wasted Children” (1976), “Chain” (1978)
- Euripides’ Elektra (~420 BCE): lines 998-1232
- This is either pp.236-245 in the PDF (English only) or pp.262-287 in the Loeb
- Reading the entire play is NOT necessary but welcomed if you would like to do so.
- Optional: Bonnie Honig, “Isemene’s Forced Choice: Sacrifice and Sorority in Sophocles’ Antigone” (2011)
When you read through these texts, consider reading them all as primary sources. How do they converse with one another? How do they illuminate or inflect your understanding of the others?
Mentorship
Before class today, meet with a research librarian to discuss library resources and research tools relevant to your project. Email Prof. Farmer a short (1-2 sentences) description of your conversation, along with the following assignment.
Required Assignment
Before class today, post your Categorized Bibliography on the course website.
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Revised Writing Into Your Thesis 1.
THURSDAY, October 27th: Senior Majors’ Speaker
This evening, we’ll host our Senior Majors’ Speaker, Prof. Sasha-Mae Eccleston. After the talk, you are invited to dinner with the faculty at Wyndham Alumnae House. If you plan to attend the talk over Zoom, please use this link to pre-register.
Friday, October 28th: [Zoom] Conversation with Prof. Eccleston & Hannah K.’s Workshop
Our Senior Majors’ Speaker, Prof. Sasha-Mae Eccleston, will join our seminar today for an open conversation about the discipline of classics, the future of the field, processes of self-care in scholarly life, and other topics of interest to our community. Class will meet over Zoom today; please check your email for a link to the meeting.
Readings
- Anne Carson, “Mimnermos: The Brainsex Paintings“
- Sasha-Mae Eccleston, “Fantasies of Mimnermos in Anne Carson’s ‘The Brainsex Paintings’ (Plainwater)“
Required Assignment
Before the start of class today, send your “Writing Into Your Thesis 2” assignment to Prof. Farmer.
Hannah K.’s Workshop
Partner: Eden
Readings
- Download required readings
- Statius, Thebaid VII.398-560
- Space and Place preface, introduction, and chapter 1
- Optional: Carole Newlands, “Statius and Ovid: Transforming the Landscape“
Friday, November 4th: Marion
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Categorized Deep Dive.
Marion’s Workshop
Partner: Elise
Readings
- Neil, Bronwen, and Pauline Allen, eds. 2020c. “The Christianisation of the Late Antique Letter-Form.” In Greek and Latin Letters in Late Antiquity: The Christianisation of a Literary Form, 24–46. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- I’d like people to focus mostly on Pages 12-23 (Common Tropes of the Christianization of the Letter and after).
- White, Carolinne, ed. 1992c. “Some Problems of Christian Friendship.” In Christian Friendship in the Fourth Century, 45–60. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511520594.004.
- Content note: there is a paragraph on the last page that is hostile to the interpretation of Christian friendship between men as erotic/gay. It is short, but note that it is there.
- Primary sources
- https://epistolae.ctl.columbia.edu/letter/358.html
- This is a letter from the abbess Eangyth to Boniface, a bishop who was in Germany at the time. I am especially trying to focus on the language of friendship and epistolary tropes. Also, Eangyth loves to quote the Bible and other writings to develop her arguments. I would prefer that people focus on “How to Begin a Letter” so if you need to skim Eangyth’s letter that is fine!
- “How to Begin a Letter”: document that contains the first line of several letters. I am interested in how all of these writers choose to open their letters. Note that the last two are both from Boniface to women, the others are from women to Boniface.
[POSTPONED: Alexander’s Workshop
Partner: Layla
Readings
- William Beck, “Dogs, Dwellings and Masters: Ensemble and Symbol in the Odyssey”.
- Xenophon, “Cynegticus” 1.1-1.2
- In translation by Michael Ehrmantraut and Gregory A. McBrayer.
- In Greek.
- Jacopo De Grossi Mazzorin and Claudia Minniti, “Dog Sacrifice in the Ancient World: A Ritual Passage?”. (Very sad, but I’m trying to be objective.)
- (Optional) Ruth Scodel, “Odysseus’ Dog and the Productive Household”]
Friday, November 11th: Hannah C. & Laken
[POSTPONED: Hannah C.’s Workshop
Partner: George
Readings
- Aristophanes’ Assemblywomen
- Read Praxgora’s speech on pages 67-75
- Selections from Lauren Taafe’s Aristophanes and Women
- “Rendering the Male Voice“
- “Staging the Comic Woman”
- Read pages 51, 52, 55 & 61
- Feel free to read the rest of the chapter if you want but it is not necessary!]
Laken’s Workshop
Partner: Celine
Readings
- Primary Sources
- Persians by Aeschylus, translation by Cristopher Collard (2008).
- Read lines 907-1077 (to the end of the play). This is on pages 26-31 of the pdf.
- You are only required to read these lines, but the entire play is attached if you want to read more.
- I have also written a short summary of the events in Persians up to line 907, in addition to some historical context and reading questions that may be helpful.
- Persians by Aeschylus, translation by Cristopher Collard (2008).
- Secondary Source: “The Gendered Construction of Emotions in the Greek and Roman Worlds,” by Jean-Noel Allard et al.
Workshop Links
Elevation Assignment
If you plan to elevate your final grade above a 3.0 this semester, you’ll need to do a set of Elevation Assignments. See the Syllabus for full details.
Today’s Elevation Assignment due date is: Revised Writing Into Your Thesis 2 [note: deadline postponed since I haven’t had a chance to send feedback yet; you’re welcome to submit any lingering required or elevation assignments instead today]
Friday, November 18th: Rose & Liam
Required Assignments
- Before class today, email your “Annotated Bibliography” to Prof. Farmer.
- Please also email me the working title of your thesis for inclusion in the Symposium program.
Rose’s Workshop
Partner: Hannah K.
Readings
[Content Warnings: rape, abduction, death]
Primary Readings: (on pdf)
- The Rape of Proserpina – Ovid’s Metamorphoses, Book V Lines 385-571
- Orpheus and Eurydice – Ovid’s Metamorphoses, Book X Lines 1-85
While you read, try and think about how the myths can work together – Are there any similarities or common themes? What role do Hades & Persephone play in the Orpheus myth and how does that connect back to their own myth?
For people more familiar with the Greek names: Proserpine/Proserpina = Persephone, Dis = Pluto = Hades, Ceres = Demeter, Jove = Jupiter = Zeus
Secondary Reading:
- Hadestown review
- Mostly just need to read the first (actual) paragraph (you can ignore the little introductory bit at the beginning) so you can get an idea of the characters & plot of the musical, the rest is a review of the actors and performance-centered stuff so you don’t need to read all of it
- A Classicist Reviews Hadestown
- Compares some of the major plot points that are different between the musical and the myths it draws from, the article also gives some description of events in the musical though plot summary isn’t its main focus
- If you run out of time you can skip this one, though I would recommend it because it’s a pretty interesting article
We’re going to mainly focus on the myths from Ovid for our class discussion, but I wanted you guys to have at least an idea of what Hadestown is about and how these two myths feature in the musical. If you’d like to listen to any (or all) of Hadestown just for fun, I highly encourage it! Some songs I would recommend include Road to Hell, Come Home With Me, Chant, If It’s True, How Long?, and Wait For Me (Reprise) as some of my favourites, but again this is just a suggestion!
Liam’s Workshop
Partner: Claire
Readings
Hi all—to prepare for my presentation on Friday, it would be great if you could read these sources before class. You should start with Lorde (only ~3 pages). We will be spending most of our time discussing Silas Jones’ play, so I’d like you to focus most of your attention on that. The Reading Guide I’ve put together should be useful for assisting your reading. I’d also like you to read from bell hooks, “Teach 14, This is Our Life” (p.165-174 according to the text, 182-191 in the pdf). If you have time and are interested, this MalcomX reading is an amazing speech on Black Nationalist political organization in the 60’s, but it is entirely optional.
Thanksgiving Break
No classes Thursday November 24th – Friday November 25th
Friday, December 2nd: Symposium I
Required Assignment
Prepare your Symposium talk. Whether you are presenting today or next week, you should plan to finalize your Symposium talk by this date.
Program
Today we’ll hear Symposium presentations from:
- Claire
- Layla
- Laken
- Rose
- Elise
- Liam
Friday, December 9th: Symposium II
Program
Today we’ll hear Symposium presentations from:
- Hannah C.
- Celine
- George
- Alexander
- Marion
- Eden
- Hannah K.
Final Deadlines
Submit your Thesis Portfolio to Prof. Farmer, your advisor, and your second reader by Dec. 16th at 12:00pm (noon) eastern.
This will also be your final chance to complete an Elevation Assignment by submitting your “Writing Into Your Thesis 3” assignment to Prof. Farmer.